Men's Shoes
-
J. Murphy Men’s Black Leather Slip-On Style Twin Gore Ankle Boots Size 12M
No reviews$84.00
Johnston & Murphy Men’s Navy Blue Leather Bollinger Chukka Boots Size 13M
No reviews$68.99
Johnston & Murphy Men’s Mahogany Leather Upper Lace-Up Chukka Boot Size 12 M
No reviews$98.99
Johnston & Murphy Men’s Black Leather Mid Top Rawles Boot Size 12 M
No reviews$74.99
Johnston & Murphy Chocolate Brown Sheepskin Shuler Chukka Boots Size 12M
No reviews$54.99
Johnston & Murphy Men’s Dark Brown Rawles Leather Boots Size 12M
No reviews$49.99
Bruno Marc Mens Beige Faux Leather Silver Accent Slip-On Flat Loafers Sz 9 - New
No reviews$44.00
Handcrafted Men's Brown Vegan Leather Flat Slip On Shoes
No reviews$54.99
Propét Men’s Black Adhesive Closure Cushion Foot Slippers Size 10 - New
No reviews$54.00
Sonoma Boys Black Faux Leather Slip-On Memory Foam Comfort Loafers Size 5
No reviews$18.00
Air Jordan 8 Retro BG Youth Black/Grey Nubuck & Aqua Blue Sneakers Sz 5Y
No reviews$139.99
Madden Black Faux Leather Lace-Up M-Cleverr Oxford Dress Shoes Sz 10.5M
No reviews$49.99
Mercanti Fiorentini Mens Cognac Brown Leather Moccasin Driver Loafers Size 13M
No reviews$59.99
Guess Mens Black & Grey With Zipper & Lace-Up Closure Rand Combat Boots Size 12M
No reviews$42.99
14Th & Union Mens Brown Leather Lace Up Cap Toe Oxford Shoes Size 11.5M - New
No reviews$54.99
Nike Air Max Men’s Wolf Gray Black VaporMax Plus Running Sneakers Sz 10.5
No reviews$148.99
Timberland Mens Brown Leather Montgomery PTO Lace-Up Shoes Size 13M - New
No reviews$124.99
New Balance 926 Women’s White Rollbar Abzorb Comfort Walking Shoes Size 7 US
No reviews$40.00
Perry Ellis America Mens Black & Grey Leather Luke Casual Sneakers Size 8.5
No reviews$29.99
G.H. Bass & Co. Mens Grey Double Zipper Closure Lace-Up Ryan Boots 8.5M - New
No reviews$59.00
Mephisto Korie Womens Black Leather Soft-Air Technology Slip-On Shoes Size 9
No reviews$75.00
Weatherproof Mens Brown Plaid Lining Thinsulate Moccasin Slippers Size XL - New
No reviews$29.00
Nike Air Mens Black & Gray Gore-Tex XCR Kahtoola Ice Grips Hiking Shoes Sz 12.5
No reviews$149.99
Nike Air Jordan 1 Retro Blue & White Leather High OG UNC Boys Sneakers Size 12C
No reviews$79.99
Nike Men's White Starred Blue Sky Force Sneakers Sz 12.5
No reviews$49.99
L.L Bean Men's Brown Leather & Fur Moccasin Shoes Sz 10
1 review$74.99
Timberland Mens Multi-Color Durable Lightweight Mesh ReBOTL Hiking Shoes Size 9.5
No reviews$44.99
Neos Black Waterproof Protective Traction Overshoe Boots Size L
No reviews$79.00
Gmedomm Mens Black Wide Width Elderly Walking Shoes Size 10 - New
No reviews$49.99
Calvin Klein Women’s Black & White KC Lumieer Sneakers Size 11 M
No reviews$38.99
Hawke & Co Men's Navy Blue Sierra Boots Sz 12M - NWB
No reviews$98.99
Skechers Mens Black Memory Foam Slip-On Sneakers Size 13 - New
No reviews$79.99
Cole Haan Mens Brown Williams Wing II Dress Shoes Sz 9.5M
No reviews$89.99
Bostonian Men's Black Crown Windsor Oxfords First Flex Leather Shoes Sz 10
No reviews$39.99
J Shoes Men's Black Sonar Mid Top Shoes Sz 11.5 - NWB
No reviews$139.99
Lacoste Men's Blue Yellow T Clip Advance Sneakers Sz 6
No reviews$42.99
Gram Scandinavia Men's Olive Green 352g Low Top Shoes Sz 12
No reviews$39.99
Dressports Men's Black Leather Oxford Shoes Sz 8M
No reviews$39.99
G.H Bass & Co. Men’s Navy Blue Bass Lucca On Board Loafers Sz 13M - NWB
No reviews$79.99
Arkbird Men's Tan Brown Leather Low Calf Oxford Boots Sz 8
No reviews$119.99
Bostonian Men's Burgundy Pollino Lace Up Shoes Sz 12M
No reviews$74.99
Johnston & Murphy Men's Rust Black Leather Brinkley Oxford Shoes Sz 12M - NWB
No reviews$149.00
Showing 84 of 89 productsFilters
F.A.Q.
Here’s everything you need to know about our vintage finds, secondhand pieces, and how we do things at Picky Thrifter.
Yup! If you're grabbing a few things, reach out or head over to our Bundles Page. We love rewarding good taste and giving you a better deal when you shop more vintage and secondhand finds together.
We source our inventory in bulk from the DMV area through a mix of trusted wholesale partners, private donations, and select liquidation sources. Every piece is thoroughly cleaned and carefully curated to meet our quality standards. This ensures our collection of secondhand clothing and vintage fashion is always fresh, unique, and ready to wear.
Mostly thrifted and vintage, with a splash of New With Tags (NWT) gems when we find them. Everything is secondhand, handpicked, and ready for a new life in your closet.
We only list vintage clothing, contemporary fashion, and secondhand pieces that meet our high standards. Every item is in either excellent or good used condition — no rips, major flaws, or heavy wear. Occasionally, there may be small, discreet marks or signs of age that don’t take away from the overall look or wearability. If an item doesn’t make the cut, we donate it back into circulation. You get to shop the best quality pre-owned fashion, ready to wear and love again.
Absolutely. Every item is hand-selected and reviewed for authenticity and quality before it’s listed. While we take every step to ensure accuracy, vintage and designer pieces can sometimes lead to differing opinions among experts. In the rare event a concern arises, we’re happy to offer a full refund and cover return shipping — no hassle. To learn more, please visit our Return and Refund Policy.
If you’re local to the DMV area, come visit our Pop-Up Store in Gaithersburg! You can see and try on many of the items listed online before making a purchase. Check out details and hours here: Pop-Up Store Info.
A: However you like — credit cards, PayPal, Shop Pay — we’ve got options.
We ship from Gaithersburg, Maryland, with a 0–1 day handling time Monday through Saturday. Orders placed before 3 PM EST ship the same day, and most U.S. orders arrive within 3–5 business days. Tracking is always included, and DMV locals can pick up at our Gaithersburg Pop-Up Store on weekends. For full details, please see our Shipping Policy.
No stress — we’ve got you covered. You can return eligible items within 30 days. Just reach out to us first using the live chat icon at the bottom right corner of every page. For all the details, check out our Return and Refund Policy.
Slide into our inbox through our Contact Us page or reach out via the live chat icon at the bottom right corner of every page — we’re always happy to help with questions about sizing, shipping, bundle deals, or vintage finds.
Pop-Up Shop
Now Open
Saturday
10am to 7pm
Sunday
10am to 5pmPop-Up Shop
Now Open
Saturday
10am to 7pm
Sunday
10am to 5pmYour Cart
🚚 Free shipping on all orders over $60 — no code needed! Offer auto-applies at checkout — don’t miss your chance to save!
Item added to your cart [count] items added to your cartCart was successfully updatedYour Cart is empty
Let's fix thatSearch our store
Popular Searches
Your Wishlist
Your wishlist is currently empty