Shoes Women + Men
-
Belle Womens Black Rhinestone Ankle Strap Back Zipper High Heel Sandals Size 6.5
No reviews$34.00
Nina Women’s Silver Jolie Strappy Rhinestone High Heel Sandals Size 8.5M
No reviews$22.99
Salvatore Ferragamo Beige Nudo Calf Leather Slingback Delier Block Heels Sz 10B
No reviews$54.99
Brighton Womens Black Patent Leather Studded Pointed Toe Heels Size 8M
No reviews$64.99
Vintage Salvatore Ferragamo Women's Green Leather Low Heel Pumps Size 5.5 B
No reviews$89.99
Salvatore Ferragamo Women’s Black Nero Pebble Leather Arcade Pumps Sz 6.5 - New
No reviews$190.00
Robert Clergerie Burgundy Leather Habana Square-Toe Block Heel Shoes Sz 5.5B-New
No reviews$175.00
Stuart Weitzman Black Suede Giveable Bow & Chain Accent Wedge Flats Size 10M
No reviews$124.99
Steve Madden Women’s Brown Perforated Leather Neptune Block Heel Sandals Sz 8.5
No reviews$39.99
Restricted Womens Beige Peep-Toe Lace-Up Back Zipper Heeled Sandals Sz 8.5
No reviews$32.99
Jean Paul Barriere Accessoire Caviar Black Pumps Suede Square Toe Shoes Sz 6
No reviews$55.00
Salvatore Ferragamo Brown Croc-Embossed Leather Block Heel Loafers Sz 5.5B- New
No reviews$198.00
Ralph Lauren Black Leather Croc Embossed Toe Low Heel Pumps Sz 6B
No reviews$125.00
Lulus Emerald Green Velvet Bow Tie Straps Block Heel Sandals Sz 10 - New
No reviews$34.00
Hush Puppies Bounce Womens Black Slingback Block Heel Shoes - NEW
No reviews$54.99
Dan Post Women’s Pink Leather Distressed Studded Western Mule Clogs 7.5M
No reviews$89.99
Vintage Jeanine Fuchsia Satin Lauren Kitten Heel Pumps Size 9M
No reviews$39.99
Vita Vanilla Braided Raffia Double Strap Block Heel Sandals Size 8 - New
No reviews$64.99
Kenneth Cole Womens Black Croc-Embossed Leather Tango ll Heels Size 7
No reviews$44.99
Zara Woman Metallic Gold Ankle Strap Heeled Sandals Size US 8
No reviews$18.99
Somethin’ Else By Skechers Brown Suede Moccasin Heels Leather Ribbon Bow Sz 6.5H
No reviews$45.00
Oripalla Womens Black Patent Leather Grace A Kitten Heels Size 7 - New
No reviews$37.99
Sacha London Black Suede Peep-Toe Buckle Strap Saba Block Heel Pumps Sz 9
No reviews$24.99
Michael Kors Black/Dark Sand Embossed Leather Cape Toe Haylen Pumps Size 9.5M
No reviews$32.99
Vintage Obel Women’s Brown Suede Leather Heel Pumps Size 5.5 US (36 EU)
No reviews$54.99
Michael Kors Studio Criss Cross Black Leather Stiletto Heeled Sandals Sz 9M
No reviews$29.99
Soft Style By Hush Puppies Women's Red Leather Low Heel Pumps Size 8W
No reviews$29.99
Steve Madden White Faux Leather Platform Block Heel Strappy Sandals Size 7M
No reviews$28.99
Easy Street Women’s Gold Faux Leather Alive 5 Block Heel Pumps Size 7M
No reviews$22.99
Nine West Black Synthetic Egotrip Cork Wedge Slip-On Sandals Size 6.5M
No reviews$49.99
Viscata Barcelona Green & Beige Espadrille Slingback Wedge Sandals Sz 10 US
No reviews$49.99
Xappeal Gemini Women’s Taupe Faux Suede Slip-On Block Heel Ankle Shoes Size 10
No reviews$24.99
Pleaser Women’s Black Faux Feather Open-Toe Mules Stiletto Heel Sz 8
No reviews$62.99
Naturalizer Women’s Brown Leather With Buckle Detail Heeled Loafers Size 10W
No reviews$24.99
Badgley Mischka Laney Ivory Satin Rhinestone Embellished Heeled Sandals Sz 9
No reviews$39.99
Giorgio Women’s Argento & Antracite Strappy Stiletto Heel Sandals Sz 8 US
No reviews$310.00
Vintage George Shoes White Leather Perforated Trim Handiwork Block Heel Size 5
No reviews$59.99
Amiana Women’s Black Patent Faux Leather Ankle Strap Block Heel Sandals Sz 7.5
No reviews$27.99
Gold Glitter Ankle Strap Yellow Lace With Rhinestone Trim Kitten Heels Sz 9.5 / 42
No reviews$20.00
White House Black Market Women’s Black Satin London Peep Toe Heels 6.5M
No reviews$29.99
Aldo Women’s Red Patent Leather Strappy Pointed Toe Heels Size 8
No reviews$49.99
Stuart Weitzman Womens Black With Bow Detail Ballet Flats Size 7.5 M
No reviews$44.99
Showing 252 of 509 productsFilters
F.A.Q.
Here’s everything you need to know about our vintage finds, secondhand pieces, and how we do things at Picky Thrifter.
Yup! If you're grabbing a few things, reach out or head over to our Bundles Page. We love rewarding good taste and giving you a better deal when you shop more vintage and secondhand finds together.
We source our inventory in bulk from the DMV area through a mix of trusted wholesale partners, private donations, and select liquidation sources. Every piece is thoroughly cleaned and carefully curated to meet our quality standards. This ensures our collection of secondhand clothing and vintage fashion is always fresh, unique, and ready to wear.
Mostly thrifted and vintage, with a splash of New With Tags (NWT) gems when we find them. Everything is secondhand, handpicked, and ready for a new life in your closet.
We only list vintage clothing, contemporary fashion, and secondhand pieces that meet our high standards. Every item is in either excellent or good used condition — no rips, major flaws, or heavy wear. Occasionally, there may be small, discreet marks or signs of age that don’t take away from the overall look or wearability. If an item doesn’t make the cut, we donate it back into circulation. You get to shop the best quality pre-owned fashion, ready to wear and love again.
Absolutely. Every item is hand-selected and reviewed for authenticity and quality before it’s listed. While we take every step to ensure accuracy, vintage and designer pieces can sometimes lead to differing opinions among experts. In the rare event a concern arises, we’re happy to offer a full refund and cover return shipping — no hassle. To learn more, please visit our Return and Refund Policy.
If you’re local to the DMV area, come visit our Pop-Up Store in Gaithersburg! You can see and try on many of the items listed online before making a purchase. Check out details and hours here: Pop-Up Store Info.
A: However you like — credit cards, PayPal, Shop Pay — we’ve got options.
We ship from Gaithersburg, Maryland, with a 0–1 day handling time Monday through Saturday. Orders placed before 3 PM EST ship the same day, and most U.S. orders arrive within 3–5 business days. Tracking is always included, and DMV locals can pick up at our Gaithersburg Pop-Up Store on weekends. For full details, please see our Shipping Policy.
No stress — we’ve got you covered. You can return eligible items within 30 days. Just reach out to us first using the live chat icon at the bottom right corner of every page. For all the details, check out our Return and Refund Policy.
Slide into our inbox through our Contact Us page or reach out via the live chat icon at the bottom right corner of every page — we’re always happy to help with questions about sizing, shipping, bundle deals, or vintage finds.
Pop-Up Shop
Now Open
Saturday
10am to 7pm
Sunday
10am to 5pmPop-Up Shop
Now Open
Saturday
10am to 7pm
Sunday
10am to 5pmYour Cart
🚚 Free shipping on all orders over $60 — no code needed! Offer auto-applies at checkout — don’t miss your chance to save!
Item added to your cart [count] items added to your cartCart was successfully updatedYour Cart is empty
Let's fix thatSearch our store
Popular Searches
Your Wishlist
Your wishlist is currently empty